Alex,
That is the problem opinions left out we all have them and that is it, your idea of a test is not the same as mine,
im not interested in how well at x angle the pole reacts, and i believe that most window cleaners dont either, im interested in what a pole works like how it handles out on the most important thing the job of cleaning windows.
sorry this sounds like a dig its not,
after all if you speak to people they all recommend different poles as they have there own opinion.
rgds, stuart
Stuart
It doesn't sound like a dig! I understand exactly what you're talking about. I always value my opinion having tried all of the poles more than any specific measurement. However, when tabulating, publishing, recommending specific products, it's always easier just to present the facts not that the facts will give the fully rounded picture (although they can certainly help).
By the way, your new poles look interesting.
I can understand why the test for rigidity is done at the angle it is for the purpose of the test but the poles are never used at that angle so i believe an upright test with a standard weight on all poles would be better although the angle of the pole would be slight depending on pole and then how do you measure the angle when its 40ft in the air... i havent thought this one through have i
leave it to the pro's
Dean
Dean
I agree with you. The ideal test would be to have the poles fully extended at an angle of about 25 degrees off of vertical with just the bottom 1 metre of the pole supported. All poles would need to be loaded at the top with the same weight, say, 500 g. Then the angle of deviation from vertical would need to be measured and represented as a percentage. This in reality would be very difficult to carry out (I haven't read the test in PWC so I don't know if they have done it like this or not). When we carried out our rigidity test, we did in the most straightforward way to tabulate and measure. Whilst this doesn't represent the angle that the pole is used at, it does give you an instant idea of which pole is the stiffest. Not the perfect test but a valid one.