This is an advertisement
Interested In Advertising? | Contact Us Here

Warning!

 

Welcome to Clean It Up; the UK`s largest cleaning forum with over 34,000 members

 

Please login or register to post and reply to topics.      

 

Forgot your password? Click here

Smudger

  • Posts: 13438
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #20 on: May 16, 2024, 08:20:05 am »
Vin - slightly off topic - do you get cheaper insurance for doing such low miles?
Never argue with an idiot, they will only bring you down to their level, and beat you with experience

֍Winp®oClean֍

  • Posts: 1687
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #21 on: May 16, 2024, 08:28:23 am »
First thing that springs to my mind is, at only 36 miles a day, is there any real saving to made at all? When you consider the elevated purchase price and uncertain future value and performance, personally, at such a low cost starting point using diesel I wouldn't bother with electric. I'm still not convinced that EV is the future.
There are now new petrol vans on the market, although I have no idea how they weigh up.
Comfortably Numb!

Arnold Palmer

  • Posts: 20775
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #22 on: May 16, 2024, 08:34:42 am »
The batteries on almost all vans have an 8 year warranty on them. Second hand or not.

Perfect Windows

  • Posts: 4179
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #23 on: May 16, 2024, 08:35:29 am »
Vin - slightly off topic - do you get cheaper insurance for doing such low miles?

Not sure. They always ask, so I assume it's taken into account.

Arnold Palmer

  • Posts: 20775
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #24 on: May 16, 2024, 08:39:05 am »
Vin - slightly off topic - do you get cheaper insurance for doing such low miles?

Not sure. They always ask, so I assume it's taken into account.

Knowing insurance companies probably not  ;D

My guess is that they ask to catch you out - if you're in an accident and you've underestimated they can refuse to pay out.

I'm very cynical though.

zesty

  • Posts: 2452
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #25 on: May 16, 2024, 08:49:06 am »
There are plenty of diagnostics available to check the battery state. Hyundai have recently said that data gathered from their sold EVs suggests their batteries will last a mere 300,000 miles before dropping to 85% capacity.  (You're also ignoring the fact that the engine could be shot on a diesel van.)

I, too, will be able to forget about range because when I wake up I'll have 80-odd miles of range and  a maximum of 36 miles to do.  I'm honestly struggling to see why I'd need a 500 mile range given that my fuel station will be on my driveway.

Vin

I do long trips in my van, I use it for all sorts, so it’s great having the range of a diesel.

If you’re only do a few miles a day, then I understand your reasoning.

Be interesting to see how you get on.


Ched

  • Posts: 440
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #26 on: May 16, 2024, 10:11:05 am »
There is an additional benefit to buying EVs that you may not know.
If you have certain types of chargers (they are all about the same cost) then Octopus Energy have an EV tariff, other companies do too but not as low a price. This is the standard 30p/kwh (what ever it is these days due to the cap) rate for most of the time but from 11:30pm to 5:30am everyday all your household electricity is only 7.5p/kwh. So we have our dishwasher and washing machines timed to come on in the cheap periods. OK so it's not a huge saving but it adds up over the year and if you are a ltd company having an ev charger installed is 20% cheaper due to some sort of Gov grant, even though it's at home!

I read peoples arguments about batteries might be on last legs etc but so might any engine - how many Ford eco tecs have gone bang, how many transits have snapped their wet belts way before any scheduled service, how many VW have had injectors fail and damage the engine?
If the battery is duff - you can get odb readers (£5) to check battery state of health and services should state the battery health, then you would replace it with a used one from a crash damaged vehicle same as you would if a diesel engine failed - you wouldn't go to the manufacturer and buy a brand new engine as it would be silly money.

As for range, yes they are significantly lower than diesels but how many need to do hundreds of miles in a day - very few but some do. If you need to do that many miles then most evs will charge from 20 to 80% in less than 1 hr. I agree not as convenient as a diesel but you never need to stop or divert to a  'petrol station' to fill up you just get home and plug in when required.

Currently EVs are not for everyone. As you may guess I bought an ev car in Feb and it's great, the instant torque is very addictive and the range is actually what the manufacturer quotes (not in winter), in fact it does more miles per kw round town than spec says - quite a bit more. By my calcs just in fuel it's costing less than 2p per mile - diesel currently at £1.52.7 a litre at 40mpg works out at 17p a mile so almost 9 times more expensive per mile in a diesel!

One thing to note, the zero tax does end in April 2025 although if you retax in May 2025 you get another 12 months at £0 so up to May 2026 you can get zero road tax.

Arnold Palmer

  • Posts: 20775
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #27 on: May 16, 2024, 10:25:11 am »
There is an additional benefit to buying EVs that you may not know.
If you have certain types of chargers (they are all about the same cost) then Octopus Energy have an EV tariff, other companies do too but not as low a price. This is the standard 30p/kwh (what ever it is these days due to the cap) rate for most of the time but from 11:30pm to 5:30am everyday all your household electricity is only 7.5p/kwh. So we have our dishwasher and washing machines timed to come on in the cheap periods. OK so it's not a huge saving but it adds up over the year and if you are a ltd company having an ev charger installed is 20% cheaper due to some sort of Gov grant, even though it's at home!

I read peoples arguments about batteries might be on last legs etc but so might any engine - how many Ford eco tecs have gone bang, how many transits have snapped their wet belts way before any scheduled service, how many VW have had injectors fail and damage the engine?
If the battery is duff - you can get odb readers (£5) to check battery state of health and services should state the battery health, then you would replace it with a used one from a crash damaged vehicle same as you would if a diesel engine failed - you wouldn't go to the manufacturer and buy a brand new engine as it would be silly money.

As for range, yes they are significantly lower than diesels but how many need to do hundreds of miles in a day - very few but some do. If you need to do that many miles then most evs will charge from 20 to 80% in less than 1 hr. I agree not as convenient as a diesel but you never need to stop or divert to a  'petrol station' to fill up you just get home and plug in when required.

Currently EVs are not for everyone. As you may guess I bought an ev car in Feb and it's great, the instant torque is very addictive and the range is actually what the manufacturer quotes (not in winter), in fact it does more miles per kw round town than spec says - quite a bit more. By my calcs just in fuel it's costing less than 2p per mile - diesel currently at £1.52.7 a litre at 40mpg works out at 17p a mile so almost 9 times more expensive per mile in a diesel!

One thing to note, the zero tax does end in April 2025 although if you retax in May 2025 you get another 12 months at £0 so up to May 2026 you can get zero road tax.

Yeah but no but yeah but no but...

Don't they explode/leave you stranded/cost more to run/need new batteries every 5 years/take 100 hours to charge/the grid can't handle it/break down all the time/blah blah blah blah blah.

 ;D

Ched

  • Posts: 440
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #28 on: May 16, 2024, 10:42:57 am »
There is an additional benefit to buying EVs that you may not know.
If you have certain types of chargers (they are all about the same cost) then Octopus Energy have an EV tariff, other companies do too but not as low a price. This is the standard 30p/kwh (what ever it is these days due to the cap) rate for most of the time but from 11:30pm to 5:30am everyday all your household electricity is only 7.5p/kwh. So we have our dishwasher and washing machines timed to come on in the cheap periods. OK so it's not a huge saving but it adds up over the year and if you are a ltd company having an ev charger installed is 20% cheaper due to some sort of Gov grant, even though it's at home!

I read peoples arguments about batteries might be on last legs etc but so might any engine - how many Ford eco tecs have gone bang, how many transits have snapped their wet belts way before any scheduled service, how many VW have had injectors fail and damage the engine?
If the battery is duff - you can get odb readers (£5) to check battery state of health and services should state the battery health, then you would replace it with a used one from a crash damaged vehicle same as you would if a diesel engine failed - you wouldn't go to the manufacturer and buy a brand new engine as it would be silly money.

As for range, yes they are significantly lower than diesels but how many need to do hundreds of miles in a day - very few but some do. If you need to do that many miles then most evs will charge from 20 to 80% in less than 1 hr. I agree not as convenient as a diesel but you never need to stop or divert to a  'petrol station' to fill up you just get home and plug in when required.

Currently EVs are not for everyone. As you may guess I bought an ev car in Feb and it's great, the instant torque is very addictive and the range is actually what the manufacturer quotes (not in winter), in fact it does more miles per kw round town than spec says - quite a bit more. By my calcs just in fuel it's costing less than 2p per mile - diesel currently at £1.52.7 a litre at 40mpg works out at 17p a mile so almost 9 times more expensive per mile in a diesel!

One thing to note, the zero tax does end in April 2025 although if you retax in May 2025 you get another 12 months at £0 so up to May 2026 you can get zero road tax.

Yeah but no but yeah but no but...

Don't they explode/leave you stranded/cost more to run/need new batteries every 5 years/take 100 hours to charge/the grid can't handle it/break down all the time/blah blah blah blah blah.

 ;D
Yes if they catch fire they are difficult to put out - how many vauxhall zafira's caught fire due to manufacturing faults with heaters?
Leave you stranded - yes if you don't recharge same as a petrol or diesel if you let the tank run dry.
Cost more to run - servicing is lower compared to petrol and diesel - tesla don't have a service schedule at all - so zero service costs!
New battery every 5 years - most manufactures warranty battery for 7 years plus - can't say that for many petrol and diesel cars.
Take 100 hrs to charge - most will go from 20% to 80% within 60 mins on a fest charger - at home on an ev charger about 10 hrs.
The grid can't handle it - they will take care of that by managing when people charge by offering cheap charging on off peak periods.
Break down all the time - not read that one before :-)

If you look back in history the amount of fuss that the petrol cars created was huge, people had to walk in front waving a flag as so dangerous, engines would scare horses, people wouldn't be able to breath going that fast (that might have been stream trains :-)) 
Most humans don't like change  ;D
The tech is definitely improving at a rate of knots and cost is coming down, don't believe manufacturers retail prices as in reality you can buy a lot at 20 to 30% off rrp, so depreciation should be measured against actual purchase price not list  ;D

I better get out and clean some glass  ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D

Perfect Windows

  • Posts: 4179
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #29 on: May 16, 2024, 11:18:28 am »
First thing that springs to my mind is, at only 36 miles a day, is there any real saving to made at all? When you consider the elevated purchase price and uncertain future value and performance, personally, at such a low cost starting point using diesel I wouldn't bother with electric. I'm still not convinced that EV is the future.
There are now new petrol vans on the market, although I have no idea how they weigh up.

I'm running out of ways to say that I'm buying used so the big depreciation on new EV's isn't a problem.

Vin

Perfect Windows

  • Posts: 4179
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #30 on: May 16, 2024, 11:32:25 am »

Yes if they catch fire they are difficult to put out - how many vauxhall zafira's caught fire due to manufacturing faults with heaters?
Leave you stranded - yes if you don't recharge same as a petrol or diesel if you let the tank run dry.
Cost more to run - servicing is lower compared to petrol and diesel - tesla don't have a service schedule at all - so zero service costs!
New battery every 5 years - most manufactures warranty battery for 7 years plus - can't say that for many petrol and diesel cars.
Take 100 hrs to charge - most will go from 20% to 80% within 60 mins on a fest charger - at home on an ev charger about 10 hrs.
The grid can't handle it - they will take care of that by managing when people charge by offering cheap charging on off peak periods.
Break down all the time - not read that one before :-)

If you look back in history the amount of fuss that the petrol cars created was huge, people had to walk in front waving a flag as so dangerous, engines would scare horses, people wouldn't be able to breath going that fast (that might have been stream trains :-)) 
Most humans don't like change  ;D
The tech is definitely improving at a rate of knots and cost is coming down, don't believe manufacturers retail prices as in reality you can buy a lot at 20 to 30% off rrp, so depreciation should be measured against actual purchase price not list  ;D

I better get out and clean some glass  ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D

I suspect that Soupy was being sarcastic about the repeated lies about EVs. (They're not errors or misunderstandings: the Daily Mail, Telegraph and Express know they are printing lies to suit their paymasters.)

The fact that people believe the scare stories is one of the reasons why, at the moment, EV secondhand prices are so low. Lunatic low. (Just a reminder that I'm buying used, not new, BTW, lest anyone forget).

In a few years , when people notice that their neighbour has used an EV for the past ten years, loves it, charges it from the solar panel on their roof and still miraculously manages to see their family 200 miles away without catching fire or breaking down, used prices will stabilise. Until then, I'll make hay.

Vin

PS. My favourite stats on fires come from an article about Tusker fleet management. (1)  They have 30,000 EVs and "the company’s insurance records show that not a single one of the EVs on its fleet have caught fire." (2) "A study by the Swedish Civil Contingencies Agency backs up Tusker’s findings. It concluded that EVs are 20 times less likely to catch fire than petrol and diesel cars."
Both quotes from an excellent article at https://www.fleetnews.co.uk/news/tusker-fleet-data-reveals-the-truth-about-ev-fires

Stoots

  • Posts: 6211
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #31 on: May 16, 2024, 12:01:38 pm »
They are just a bit "gay" for want of a better phrase.  Mileage is crap and you can't hear them coming.

Give me a smokey old diesel that leaks a bit of oil and if something goes wrong I can get under the bonnet and get my hands dirty. I want something that kicks out some fumes and makes a bit of a noise.


Arnold Palmer

  • Posts: 20775
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #32 on: May 16, 2024, 12:27:15 pm »
They are just a bit "gay" for want of a better phrase.  Mileage is crap and you can't hear them coming.

Give me a smokey old diesel that leaks a bit of oil and if something goes wrong I can get under the bonnet and get my hands dirty. I want something that kicks out some fumes and makes a bit of a noise.

Drive one for a while.

It won't make you a gayer.

Perfect Windows

  • Posts: 4179
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #33 on: May 16, 2024, 12:34:56 pm »
They are just a bit "gay"   "perfect for the work Vin does" for want of a better phrase.  Mileage is crap beautifully sufficient and you can't hear them coming they are nice and quiet to drive.

Fixed that for you.

Vin

֍Winp®oClean֍

  • Posts: 1687
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #34 on: May 16, 2024, 12:36:05 pm »
First thing that springs to my mind is, at only 36 miles a day, is there any real saving to made at all? When you consider the elevated purchase price and uncertain future value and performance, personally, at such a low cost starting point using diesel I wouldn't bother with electric. I'm still not convinced that EV is the future.
There are now new petrol vans on the market, although I have no idea how they weigh up.

I'm running out of ways to say that I'm buying used so the big depreciation on new EV's isn't a problem.

Vin

No, I fully read AND understood your post. Mine was, and still is, bssed on that!
Comfortably Numb!

Perfect Windows

  • Posts: 4179
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #35 on: May 16, 2024, 12:44:38 pm »
No, I fully read AND understood your post. Mine was, and still is, bssed on that!

I don't get your "elevated purchase price" at all then.

Five year old
Mercedes E-Sprinter, 8,000 miles £12.4k
VW E-Transporter, 9,000 miles £9.8k

Compare with
Five year old
Citroen Dispatch, 109k miles £8k
Toyota Proace, 41k miles £12k

Not "elevated" by my reckoning.

Vin




֍Winp®oClean֍

  • Posts: 1687
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #37 on: May 16, 2024, 02:10:34 pm »
No, I fully read AND understood your post. Mine was, and still is, bssed on that!

I don't get your "elevated purchase price" at all then.

Five year old
Mercedes E-Sprinter, 8,000 miles £12.4k
VW E-Transporter, 9,000 miles £9.8k

Compare with
Five year old
Citroen Dispatch, 109k miles £8k
Toyota Proace, 41k miles £12k

Not "elevated" by my reckoning.

Vin

That's because nobody wants them!😁
That alone should be enough to warn you off. Horses for courses though.🙂
Comfortably Numb!

Perfect Windows

  • Posts: 4179
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #38 on: May 16, 2024, 02:23:00 pm »
That's because nobody wants them!😁
That alone should be enough to warn you off. Horses for courses though.🙂

I think you are entirely correct.

The Jester of Wibbly

  • Posts: 2160
Re: Electric vans
« Reply #39 on: May 16, 2024, 02:46:41 pm »
Those DFSK vans seem cheap and chips to buy. 
Claim your 50% off your mobile payment card reader with Sum Up.  http://fbuy.me/f7Ve3