I've removed a few non essential posts, (sorry to those that have had them removed by the way) as this has remained a well debated topic and seems to be full of steam, ergo locking it isn't necessary just yet.
Ross has joined the debate now and added his views, so a couple may wish to respond.
Me for one
My own experience differs from ross's, I've had very little in the way of complaints and by and large I've found that my standards have gone up across the board.
Spotting and other problems are down to user error, I still get the odd bit of spotting, but it is minimal and even on a first time clean the glass comes up mint.
Almost all my work is commercial, and almost all of it is done with the WFP, obviously is you have work in Malls and so on you can hardly use WFP, but I guess that really depends on the nature of your work.
I would also read the thrust of the posts in this thread differently too Ross, I don't think there are any that are 100% WFP on everything and anti trad, not even 'anti' ladders, more a case of interpreting the regs differently.
On that point (and I am really not trying to get you going on that subject...honest!!! I've read many of your posts on the subject and know how you feel about H & S!!) I know of one window cleaner that was actually cleaning the windows of a local Health and safety officer, and being concerned about the new regs he asked him his views on it.
The local Officer interpreted it (and he had just come back from a seminar) in that as you were only working off a ladder for a couple of minutes at a time you were ok, don't worry about it, carry on as normal but just observe safe practice when using your ladders.
Even Safety Officers themselves will differ in their own interpretation in the regs, so it's understandable that we all have different opinions.
For me, Philip Hanson's interpretation makes the most sense of all...and thats the thing...it DOES make sense!!
Maybe I shouldn't have said anything about the regs now that Ross has joined the debate!
His views differ to Philip's and he is equally well read on the subject too
Oh well, I'm off to work, coming up to 6.30am so I need to get going!
As the thread hasn't run out of steam we'll let it run a little longer, I'll keep removing the 'chaff' when I see it...except that pic Roger posted, we'll leave that one for now
Unless someone complains about the gratuitous use of a scantilly glad female with a pole in her hand of course
Ian