What an excellent review. I haven't read either coaches book or his dossier, but your thoughts together with the little bits i gleaned when he was on here give the giste.
I was surprised at how many people posted against him and how strongly they seemed to feel. I found him very energising and definitely someone i could spark off.
I was disapointed that he scarpered and used the lame excuse that he had been banned. He could have either stumped up for the right to harangue us into signing up with him, or simply re-registered under another name and joined in without overt recruitment.
We have other experts on here, Alex being one often cited, so why not a marketing expert?
While i was impressed with him it was apparent that there were large gaps in his knowledge about us and the UK market. For a start he didn't fully grasp WFP, or what it mean't (it means we can do the job faster and earn more money),nor did he fully understand our business model in terms of obtaining regular repeat customers.
As for the re-worked real life examples that you would have liked to have seen how else would he obtain these other than by talking to us?
My opinion is that he definitely has something to offer and anyone who feels they are on a mission to become a window cleaning contender could do a lot worse than sign up with him. If you have any fire at all in your belly he could very likely turn you into a furnace.