Dave
Quite a few years ago, I stepped back a bit and looked at why I was advertising in Y/P and whether I needed it. Like Doug, it is/wasn't a critical part of my marketing strategy. I came to the conclusion that I didn't need Y/P to provide me with work. What I did need though was a medium to which customers who knew of me or had previously used my services, could turn to to find my number. Yellow Pages is the biggest name in directories, so was just right for me. I now had a choice. Buy space or just use the free listing. I decided to buy some space. As I'm an NCCA Member, I used their Corporate Advertising facility to have my name and business represented in a larger corporate advert. In my directory it costs me £130ish plus V.A.T. Excellent value for money, pays for itself many times over and tends to attract more people interested in quality rather than price. Also fulfills my primary objective for people to find me by name.
Perhaps if you step back and look at your needs and the tools you use, you will then be able to see more clearly what's right for you.
Safe and happy cleaning:)
Ken