IMO you cant beat showa 377s with nitrile glove liners underneath.they keep your hands clean and dry and they dont smell.totally waterproof as well.ok for trad too.not too cumbersome.
not that warm but if you use hot water the warm hose and pole keep hands warm.its not been that cold this winter anyway.
during a cold spell(minus temperatures)ill wear glacier "perfect curve" neoprene gloves again with glove liners underneath to stop hands smelling.works a treat.
£6 a pair for the showa 377s(i buy 3 pairs at a time and they last around 3 months worn every day)
£5 for 100 pairs of nitrile glove liners(worn for 2 days then binned)so 200 working days out of one packet.